first published in The Lion Roars issue no 221 reproduced with the kind permission of the editor
Like a lot of people who couldn’t get tickets for Southampton, I settled down to watch the game on Sky. The game was screened in our local hotel but there was only one other Millwall supporters with me, & the rest of the clientele were made up of lunchtime diners. The result being that the sound had to be quite low meaning I missed some key incidents & the atmosphere was decidedly subdued for a Lions game. I watched the game end to end, and although happy with a draw I was disappointed with some of our play. Later that evening I met up with a few mates & I was amazed to find that their view of the game was totally at odds with my own.
So let’s start with what I saw (and this has been written completely independent of any other match review in TLR or elsewhere):-
Going into the game I thought Southampton would be disjointed and suffering from the off field goings on. Millwall by contrast had a settled side and had enjoyed a good pre-season. I reckoned if we took the game to them this was as good a chance to beat one of the top rated sides as we were going to get. I thought the Lions started well and moved the ball about brightly. But after about 15 minutes we started to punt the ball long up from the back. All too often their central defenders collected it and played it out of defence. Passes were missed by our midfield and we seemed disjointed. A couple of good chances went to Southampton, notably Schneiderlin’s lob & Perry’s volley hitting the post. Just before half time though, Morison scuffed a tight ball in the area, sending us in at 0-0.
The 2nd half started out the same way and I despaired as the Saints were allowed to play football around us with no tackles being made. When we did get the ball we gave it away cheaply. After 51 minutes almost inevitably the ball breaks to Paterson in the area who drills it home. The Lions responded in the best way and started to take the game to Southampton, the ball being played out of defence, and crisp passes tore their midfield apart. This was helped by the introduction of Ali Fuseini and Jason Price for Bolder and Martin. The pressure mounted & we had several corners before the penalty. Yes it was a definite penalty long before Price was bundled to the floor. Shame Dunny couldn’t convert it but the Lions kept the pressure up and minutes later a lovely looping header from Jimmy Abdou puts us level. Then I saw a 2nd very good penalty shout when a Saints defender under pressure from Alexander handled the ball pushing it out over the line. Price had the ball in the back of the net only for the linesman to disallow it. The Lions finished strongly but overall I thought a draw was all we deserved. Our defence was excellent despite key players being unavailable, but too often our midfield were either by-passed or ineffectual.
So what had other people seen? Now Peter has, like me, been a Lions supporter for well over 30 years, travelling home & away so he’s no mug when it comes to calling a game. And Liam may only be in his mid teens but his knowledge of soccer in general & all things Millwall in particular is almost encyclopaedic (Ah yes, I remember the good old days before age, alcohol & controlled substances took their toll on my neuron receptors. Nowadays I can barely remember my name!). He also plays in a very well respected youth team, so you would expect him to give a good valid opinion. But we had three different people and three different verdicts, and that’s before you mention Keith who attended the game and gave a fourth interpretation on the match.
Pete said he thought Millwall had played really well and had held the upper hand throughout. He felt that our strikers had created chances against an experienced and well drilled defence. Our midfield & defence had played well, specially given the fact several were playing out of position.
Liam concurred up to a point, feeling that our midfield were not aggressive enough but that when they had the ball they played well. Neither saw the repeated hoofing the ball from the back that frustrated me so much, or spotted the 2nd handball penalty shout.
Now I know opinions are like arseholes – we all have one but think everyone else’s stinks more than our own – but this is ridiculous. So what is going on?
We all know that watching a game live is totally different to watching it on TV. The way the human eyes & brain handle information just isn’t designed to work with the way TV coverage is presented to us. For a start the eye is drawn to movement and variations in colour, hence the rotating, moving advertising boards around the edge of pitches these days (which is bloody infuriating in my opinion). Also the eye focuses on one item (or player) for a split second then moves on to another, then another, then another around the field of vision. All this information is relayed to the brain which tries to make sense of all the information that is being input to it. So when you are sitting in the East Upper and you watch Forde kick the ball out of goal your eye may first focus on the keepers kick then switch for an instant to the run of Hackett as he traces the balls movement, then switch to the ref to see what position he’s in, then switches again to Alexander who is wrestling with his marker, then switches again to the 20 year old shapely blonde girl who has just jumped out of her seat in the West Lower, then switches again to the run of Morison as he draws his defender away from the ball. From this split second snap shot your brain will make an informed opinion of what is happening. Now watch that on TV and the director will use a wide angle shot to follow the movement of the ball following the kick, then switch to a tight shot of Alexander as he & his marker move to meet the ball, hence missing all the peripheral action. It’s also a bloody shame as that blonde is quite fit in my opinion.
The brain has to then interpret all this information, but will take its cues from other factors such as noise, sensory movement, tension and the like. So was my reaction to the game just a reflection of my surroundings & my overriding sense of frustration? There was no “big match atmosphere” in the pub, I was straining to hear the commentary over inane chitter chatter in my ear, plus my own over-riding sense of pessimism. So was I watching the game I EXPECTED to see? After the initial few minutes my pessimism took over & I no longer expected Millwall to play well. As a result my mind emphasised all their mistakes while playing down their good points. On the other hand, those eternal optimists Pete & Liam were willing Millwall to win so enjoyed the draw much more. It’s certainly something to be considered isn’t it, and explains the massive discrepancies in our opinions of a match with our mates. Maybe we should all refrain from watching Millwall unless we are certified as being in a happy mood – or barking mad of course.
























